I admitted recently, in a comment on my post about my bad Indian habits, that I’ve developed a rather rude habit of often pretending that I’m not at home when people turn up unannounced. I don’t answer the door. It’s definitely not something I’m proud of, but it’s something that I’ve had to do to save my sanity.
Without a doubt, the lack of privacy in Mumbai and India in general, has been the biggest challenge for me.
I feel that I’ve adapted well enough to most other things.
I eat whatever Indians eat (and can eat with my hands while sitting on the floor), drink plain water, cook Indian food, have given up toilet paper, take the train and auto rickshaws to get around, know how to drape a sari, and live in a small one bedroom apartment that’s a quarter of the size of my house in Australia. I washed clothes by hand, using a bucket and brush, for two years. I also managed to survive last year’s nine month water shortage, where water only came for a couple of hours three times a day and there was never any water to flush the toilet.
I remember when I first moved to Mumbai and was completely overwhelmed with my new surroundings, all I wanted was a sanctuary that I could retreat to and forget about what was outside. Usually, such a place would be my home. There certainly aren’t many other options in this extremely crowded city.
The fact that I couldn’t get any solitude even in my home reduced me to tears of frustration on many occasions.
The landlord turned up unannounced to collect his mail. The boys from the apartment complex wanted me to retrieve their cricket balls from the balcony. The girls wanted me to retrieve their shuttle cocks. The internet and cable TV providers wanted payment (no bills in the mail here, they come and collect the money personally). The kachra walla (sweeper/garbage guy) wanted access to the balcony, to clean up the garbage that the people from the apartments above constantly threw onto it.
Then the worst thing of all, the Aunties who came to inspect the apartment and satisfy their curiosity about me. Without fail, they would head straight to the kitchen and look through my cupboards and refrigerator to see what food was there. (Indians have trouble believing that an educated white girl can cook and take care of a home). Nothing was off limits to them, including the bedroom.
I couldn’t relax. I felt like I had to be properly dressed and ready to receive whoever came a knocking at any time. I felt like I had no privacy at all. It was made worse because I come from a very small family, with no brothers and sisters, who live in the country. I’ve been used to having a lot of privacy and personal space.
The only way to deal with it was to stop answering the door.
Fortunately, I’m more settled and a lot better at handling all this now. In a way, it’s even been good for me. I’ve learned to become more open, more flexible, and less caring about what people think of me. However, there are days when I still need solitude. Those are the days that the door doesn’t get opened.
© 2009, Diary of a White Indian Housewife. All rights reserved. Do not copy and reproduce text or images without permission.
Related Posts:
- Dealing With Water Cuts in Mumbai
- India Mystery #508: The Water Supply
- The Quality of Life in Mumbai
- Introducing the Typical Indian Bathroom
- Why I Will Leave Mumbai
- Monsoon Rain in Mumbai
- Introducing 3 Typical Indian Cleaning Implements
- Adjusting to Having a Maid
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.











{ 95 comments… read them below or add one }
← Previous Comments
If god is the universe, then it’ll be just the universe, there will be no god.
There could be, but that not in the realm of divinity. Personally, I think belief in god is a lot like being under the influence of LSD or cocaine.
If you pop some LSD, you might. A lot of people do.
Abdullah, I am not any authority to proclaim it, but yes, it’s the Universe itself from what we see happening around us, from how all natural elements co-exist. People felt the need to give it a “human” form, so that’s how the notion of God came up. It’s just a relative notion.
Divinity is somewhat connected to or represents the Universe, from the facts that most people attach to it. So, if you believe in the existence of a Universe, intrinsicly you believe in the existence of Divinity, only to different parameters. Just my view on atheism…
Indian American, I dont wish to “see” God. What good will it do to me? I just feel this world was arranged, organized and maybe even goverened by some force, which I feel is a positive one, who can relate to each one of the world’s beings, when in need. I cling to that, I feel it, I ask and I am being offered. What more could I need?
Claudia, some people say all creation in this universe is equally important to God. When it comes to being special, according to my thinking, only God is special. We all are Gods creation. So we should thank God for creating us. Whatever we have and experience is not ours. It comes from the force that created us and everything around us. We call God as a power, a force etc but I dont think God can be defined by Gods creation. God is beyond everything.
Okay people, lets drop the discussion about god and come back to the topic which is about living in Mumbai. So how is the weather in Mumbai now? Chilly? Humid? Windy?
It’s really pleasant. I wish it was like this all year! It’s around 30 degrees Celsius during the day and 20 degrees at night. Night time temperatures have dropped to around 13 degrees recently though.
Night time temperatures have dropped to around 13 degrees recently though.
Can’t beat kolkata.
It was recently 11 degrees at night.
Oh yes, I head about that. We were just discussing it last night because one of our friends is here from Kolkata. Chilly!
i totaly understand you, it was horrible for me too this lack of privacy in India but i took atitude and i told to my inlaws and all my husband family that i will not accept such behaviour, when is necessary dont let the people to cross your limits, make clear what you want dont be shy. You are great!
Hi Julya, I wish I could’ve been like that. Unfortunately, being assertive is one of my weak points — and I think part of my experience living in India is to teach me how to be more assertive! Thanks so much for the encouragement.
Sharell. Sabse pehle, I admire you for leaving everything you had back home for something as overwhelming and Mumbai. Usually, people who grow up in Mumbai(Mere jaise), end up moving to developed First World countries like Australia, USA, Canada etc to find better living standard and to escape day to day hassles and lack of privacy. But you coped up with city like Mumbai. It’s really humbling how you left everything to be with love of your life. Mumbai has all extremes, be it cold, summer, or monsoon. Don’t ever think you are being rude by not answering door bell. Auntie log bahut nosy hote hai! Kuchh kaam nahi bas neighbor ke ghar ke andar jake chhan been karo. Be assertive and Sab Chalta hai! Remember that. Hope your stay in India is better from what I experienced there
. Oh by the way, chuha pakda kya?
Hi Abhinav, actually aaj kal main ne chuha nahi deka. Abhi, kitchen window bandh rehta hai, toh chuha bahar rehta hai!!
Lekin vo kutta bahut problem hai. Main is ke bare me bahut naraz hoon. I’m glad you feel that way about the aunties, and that it’s a common issue!! Fortunately, they don’t bother me where we’re living now. Instead I have the kutta to deal with!! I can understand why people who grew up in India would want to move to the west for a better lifestyle, having not had that. However, when you have it all your life (like I did) it’s good to experience something else.
ok this is the life of one Australian woman in mumbai.. not all..Im sorry u hv to go through with all that dear. Keep the door closed when ever u wanna..its ur door okay..
I totally understand this issue- and I do the same thing. My little lane in Bandra seems to be full of people coming by hoping i’ll buy cleaning supplies, Chai, newspaper subscriptions…..anything really! Some mornings, I just don’t answer the door. If it’s my landlord, he’ll call me. If it’s anyone else….I need my sanity sometimes!
OMG I relate to the lack of privacy. When staying with my fiance, from the moment we wake up there are his servants coming in the bedroom, come living room, come office, etc.,. then his brother, cousins, business associates who come in to use the computer etc.,. it goes on and on. In the evening it’s a communial dinner. If I get time alone I lock the door and answer whomever through the closed door. They just think it is strange that I wish my own space. I think that really is the biggest difference in our cultures ‘this is my space and you’re in it!!!’ My fiance says that I am selfish that I wish to spend time with him alone…. :/ Gotta laugh or go loopy….
I think I’ve both laughed and gone loopy…. it’s an insane kinda laugh!
Dear Sharell,
I just cam across your blog today as I was googl-ing about how life would be when you live in Mumbai. And I must say I have seen Mumbai through your writings. And how much at times I can relate to your writings as I am in Perth and how much I miss India (home)!
Hi Kaushika, welcome to the blog! I’ve been to Perth — it’s so different to Mumbai. Kind of opposite really. It’s beautiful and spacious, but so quiet.
Perth is the most isolated city in the world…I haven’t been there, but always thought about visiting that place..If you have time and patience, please tell me more about that place.
You are phenomenal Sharell. Kudos!!
Awww, thanks! ***Blushes***
How do you survive without toilet paper?????
To be honest, as shocking as it may seem, I prefer water now. It’s much more cleaner.
I just looked up for your name on youtube and found out your two-three videos.
and your appartment (ex-appartment now I suppose)…
Really Sharell its a display of too much sacrifice you would have done with for all this… Hats off to you man!!!!
I have been spying your life through whatever material I ‘d get to know on the net like now for 3 days and find it to be a story of a brave girl…
Sharell!! Tusi gr88888 ho!!!!!
What? I thought my videos were set to private… for the exact reason that people do spy on me!!
Oh well, I guess I should be glad that you’ve pointed out that they are not. Yes, it was the old apartment, and those videos were supposed to be private — pre House Hunters show (US TV show we were on).
Anyway, have now closed my You Tube account because it’s not relevant anymore and I don’t use it.
Well don’t go with the word ‘spy’ so seriously Sharell !!!
I am just a CA student from Punjab, and it was just a random search Ma’am!!
Chalo!!! Atleast it prompted you to reply twice….
A 3 day search for information about me on the net isn’t spying — it’s cyber stalking!!
Sharell…..
Should I just come & tell u that I am preparing for my CA exams but yaa I was kind of interested to read on more about u…
I think you have forgotten what I ‘ve told that I am an aspiring Chartered Accountant currently residing in Punjab…
I told you my real sister is in Sydney… and at last I’m only 26… so now u can plz release me without any charge!!!
And yaa 3 day means its been 3 days since I came to know of your blog…
Sharell…
I hope I don’t need more clarifications to prove myself…
So now can I expect some good words from u???
Jai Mata Di!!!
Now I know even non-Indians are too suspicious!!!
Hey, it’s okay, I’m sure you’re a great guy. But if you were me for a day, you’d know I’m not being “suspicious”. I’ve had to block many of my online profiles, including facebook, because of the amount of weird messages I was receiving from random Indian guys (including all kinds of offers of sex) and other people wanting to get in touch.
I’m not very comfortable with being a “public figure”, but that’s the way it goes I guess!
Thank u Sharell for sharing ur views…
Yup!!! U should be used to such things now… These things r part of life. I feel ur youtube videos didn’t reveal anything new..U’ve already shared ur hubby’s pic…
Thank u for being nice (friend)-if u’d allow without again being feeling offended/unpleasant…
Okay now I must study…
Sorry again I meant non-born Indians…
U r by the way now officially white Indian!!!
Sorry again!!! I meant non-born Indians…
U r by the way now an Indian!!!
Sorry …..
Gd’day sharrell,
Bloody oath commend you on ur versatility adjusting so well. Well people from Mumbai are different, it all boils them to their roots & upbringing. U will be amazed to have many Indians living, eating, cooking, communicating at home all very much like westerners especially the Catholics form Mumbai living in queen suburbs like Bandra, Seven bungalows et all. Reckon ur doing pretty well mate.
Being a mumbaikar originally but now converted to an Australian, whenevr I return to Mumbai is living hell!!!, the noise, the kids screming, TV blarring, rickshaws rattling, people everywhere, the humidity. I run to GOA. Good on ya, yes its tollerance put to the test.
Cheers,
Hef.
Good on ya, mate!
You sound a lot like a friend of ours. Born and brought up in Mumbai (Catholic from Bandra), and has been living in Australia for the past 7 years. He seems more fair dinkum Aussie than me now, and has a few issues coping with Mumbai.
You can read about his attempts to find an Esky and ice here: http://www.whiteindianhousewife.com/2011/03/the-difficulty-of-keeping-things-chilled-in-india/
Hello Sharell, I agree with you completely on the lack of privacy. I am an Indian woman with a strong sense of needing my own space. I live alone, but go batty when my parents visit as there is an endless stream of carpenters, AC_servicemen, maids,newspaper, cable, dhobhi etc. Left to myself, I rarely open the door.
It helps to cultivate a slightly eccentric/mildly crazy image with the neighbours. They will keep their distance.
Another thing that may help is to make some arrangements to prevent people from coming up to your door-for instance, I leave the garbage out in the morning, clothes for ironing with the security (so it can be picked up there). Buy milk in tetrapacks.The newspapers are just left outside my door. I tell them not to ring my doorbell. I call the cable guy around the beginning of every month and give him a time and day to come collect payments,etc.
All my bad behaviour is cancelled out by my parents during their annual visit, when they visit the neighbours, bearing gifts and all.
Good luck to you and I can really empathise!
← Previous Comments